Reviews of specific carving products by those who've used them.
User avatar
By shaft28
I've only used blue but that is because it is the most contrast color to orange. Usually only see red and yellow so didn;t think those would work well - unless you have a black craft pumpkin (which is usually to glossy so the saral rub doesn't stick and smears super easy).
User avatar
By Zombie Pumpkins!
Any color should work really. Shaft got it... blue is only the suggestion because blue is the exact opposite of orange, so it creates the highest contrast.
User avatar
By Pargolf
The only one I would not recommend is the graphite. Does not consistently transfer as well as the other colors. I have used the white for years
User avatar
By Raven
I swore I replied to this but I must not have hit "submit".

I have the graphite and while it transferred well for me it was a mess. It rubbed all over the 'kin and was a lot harder to wash off. I had black on my 'kins everywhere that year.

I find Saral cheapest on Ebay. I keep checking throughout the year and sometimes can find a really great deal on it. If I need some right away Amazon is my go to place.